Do you toss and turn when dreaming of new bedding? Don’t worry — we’re here to comfort you!
When looking for bedding, one of the most important parts is the comforter, adding a thick (or thinner) layer of cushion and warmth to your bedding cocoon.
Especially in the middle of winter, finding the perfect comforter for your heat preferences is imperative — do you sleep hot and need something breathable, or do you sleep cold and need a thick blanket of down filling to keep you warm at night?
The time to buy is right now, as we’re right in the rut of bed-rotting season. Through the holiday season, find some of the best sleep accessories and home goods on sale, from some of your favorite retailers like Sleep Number, Cozy Earth, and more.
No matter your need, we have rounded up the best comforters based on top reviews from satisfied customers, most likely reviewing from the comfort of their bed.
Pros:
- Customizable weight options (light, all-season, and ultra-warm)
- 100% cotton sateen shell
- Treated with antimicrobials
- Lenient return policy
Cons:
- Feels a bit on the flatter side (versus fluffy)
- Some reviewers mention sizing was off when placed on a duvet cover
There are a few reasons we have placed the Brooklinen comforter at the top of this list. This comforter is made just for you — shoppers can select between three heat levels: light, all-season, and ultra-warm. For someone who prefers a lighter comforter (which is not all that typical), we truly appreciate having the flexibility to select what works best. Best of all, shoppers can slash 15% off their first order and take advantage of expedited holiday shipping.
Editor’s Note: “The design of this comforter is very impressive,” shared Commerce Reporter, Miska Salemann. “Baffle box construction ensures that the hypoallergenic downfill is evenly distributed, so there’s no constant need to re-fluff. That means more comfort and less fuss. I adore the 100% cotton sateen shell — it’s soft, breathable, and in my experience, extremely friendly with sensitive skin. This type of material also washes very easily. My only negative remark is the sizing, which seems to be slightly off when paired with certain duvet covers. Some reviewers also seem to agree that this comforter is more on the narrow side, so depending on your duvet, it may not always stay in place.”
Sizing: Twin — California King | Material: Down, Cotton and Sateen Shell
Pros:
- Choose different warmth levels on both sides of the comforter
- Choose between the lofty down alternative or the luxurious, 700-fill-power down on both sides
- Corner loops attach to the optional duvet cover to prevent the comforter from shifting
Cons:
- A couple more assembly steps than ordinary comforters
Meet the comforter that could help prevent some divorces. These intelligently engineered half comforters easily zip together to allow you and your sleep partner to enjoy your own tailored heat levels and fill preference at the same time (that means no more fighting over the blanket). Plus, right now, save up to 40% on bedding during Sleep Number’s holiday sale!
Editor’s Note: “I was very excited to try this comforter, mostly because I wanted to find out whether I would really be able to tell if there was a difference between the two sides. Mine came in a light and medium warmth on each side — and I was exceptionally impressed with the fact that these heat levels (although close together) were still noticeably different. Assembly does take an additional step, but I thought it was quite straightforward. Simply zip the two sides together and throw them in a duvet. Another great touch? This comforter features corner loops that attach to the optional duvet cover and help prevent the comforter from shifting — one of my biggest pet peeves,” said Salemann.
Sizing: Half Queen | Material: Down Alternative or Down
Pros:
- Unique design on both sides
- Comes in many colors
- Soft and cozy, per testing
Cons:
- Some reviewers mention it is not as fluffy as they hoped
This comforter from Bedsure has over 15,000 overwhelmingly positive reviews on Amazon, and one of our writers swears it’s the best she’s ever tried. Of course, one of the top-selling points is the fact that it comes in an array of lovely patterned designs, which instantly brighten up a space. Not to mention, you won’t need to add a duvet cover! This comforter stands alone.
Editor’s Note: “Not only is it available in a ton of fun bright colors and reversible (one side features a colored background with a white floral print while the other is white accented with colored flowers) to go with every room and fit every season, but it’s soft and cozy, too,” noted Commerce Reporter, Angela Tricarico. “As someone who doesn’t like to overheat at night, it’s perfect for the winter, too. It offers the perfect amount of warmth paired with my other sheets, but it’s still breathable enough to prevent overheating.”
Sizing: Twin — King | Material: Polyester
Pros:
- 750-fill-power (the highest we reviewed)
- Soft sateen for a crisp exterior
- Two heat/weight levels are available
If you’re prepared to dish out a few hundred dollars on a top-quality comforter, we suggest you go with the Down Duvet Insert from Parachute. This comforter is made with European white down and has a fill power of 750 (the highest we have reviewed). Soft sateen is sewn around the down to provide a crisp, glossy exterior. The brand also purchases its own materials from RDS-certified suppliers, meaning that it is sourced from humanely treated ducks and geese.
Editor’s Note: “Curious what this super-high-count down filling feels like? For me, it’s like floating on top of a cloud. In fact, I barely could feel my mattress while wrapped up in this comforter. The only problem is I’ll never want to get up in the morning. It’s an all-encompassing, feathery material that never gets old. The bottom line on this 750-fill-power duvet insert: it’s worth the splurge,” explained Salemann.
Sizing: Twin — California King | Material: Sateen
Pros:
- Custom fill type (bamboo or silk) and fill amount (standard or extra)
- Naturally temperature-regulating fabric ideal for warmer sleepers
- Very plush
Cons:
- More expensive
- Not ideal for colder sleepers
The Post Wanted team adores Cozy Earth for all things sleep — if you haven’t tried the brand’s gorgeous bamboo pajama sets, we recommend stopping everything you’re doing and ordering one now. It’s no surprise that Cozy Earth also supplies state-of-the-art comforters. Plus, customers can save 40% with Cozy Earth’s limited-time holiday deals!
For a different fabrication, try the Cozy Earth customizable comforter, which can be made with either 100% mulberry silk or bamboo filling — and two different fill levels available. These luxurious fabrics have a smoother feel than most cotton designs and are better for warmer sleepers, as they provide a temperature-regulating quality that keeps you from overheating and allows you to achieve longer deeper sleep.
Editor’s Note: “I have the Cozy Earth Bamboo Viscose Comforter on my king-sized bed and it’s miraculous,” shared Commerce Reporter and Content Strategist, Victoria Giardinia. “It’s a splurge but, if you want hotel-like bedding, this is your best resort. I have mine stuffed inside the brand’s Bamboo Duvet and it’s the fluffiest, softest material I’ve ever experienced. Not gonna lie, I never want to leave my bed. As its name suggests, the brand is supremely cozy and doesn’t shy away from premium fabrics that are moisture-wicking and breathable. It holds up well in the wash, too, and doesn’t wrinkle. As a whole, it looks great, feels great, and allows you to feel a taste of luxury from your bedroom.”
Sizing: Twin, Queen/Full, King | Material: Bamboo or silk
Pros:
- Attractive design
- Doubles-sided
- Inexpensive
Cons:
- Woven texture is a personal preference – not ideal for sleepers who desire a silky, soft feel
Some people like a bit of texture with their comforters. In that case, try out the Degrees of Comfort Waffle Weave comforter. This set combines breathable microfiber and a classic embossed weave that provides visual appeal and a unique feel that is a bit less engulfing than your typical down comforter material.
On the weight scale, this comforter hits right in the center. In terms of aesthetics alone, this is an easy favorite. The tight weave is certainly much more attractive than a plain surface. One side is flat — so those who prefer sleeping on something smooth can enjoy the best of both worlds.
This comforter adds plenty of warmth and it’s quite attractive, but it may not be at the top of the list for silkiness or smoothness. At just $39.99, we think it’s a great choice for those who are looking to save on their bedding.
Sizing: Full/Queen, King | Material: Microfiber
Pros:
- Inexpensive
- A variety of colors and styles are available
- Machine washable
- The set includes pillow shams
Cons:
- Less breathable than some competitors
Bedsure’s comforters do not disappoint. While they may not have that expensive goose-down feeling, they do feel great on the wallet — and they’re designed with a unique brushing technique that makes the shell of the comforter quite soft and attractive. It’s available in so many color options and styles, that you don’t even need a duvet cover.
Editor’s Note: “The premium microfiber filling is not quite as weightless as the true down fillings, but it’s still exceptionally cozy and I hardly experienced any clumping when I put this comforter in a sheet. Everything fell flat with a few shakes and stayed that way all night long,” added Salemann. “For someone looking for an unfussy, straightforward, and all-around reliable comforter, we’d go with Bedsure in a heartbeat. You’ll save hundreds and still achieve restful sleep.”
Sizing: Twin — California King | Material: Microfiber
Pros:
- Best budget-friendly option
- Slides less than some silkier comforters
- Provides medium warmth and weight (ideal for most sleepers)
- Duvet cover is not necessary
Cons:
- Not quite as silky as some premium comforters
- Take up to two days to fluff up
For the best budget option, consider this duvet insert from Nestl. Unlike many of the other comforter options, this insert is quilted with a 100% polyester shell. This quilt may offer less of the desirable silky feel associated with some higher-end comforters, however, it’s still very soft to the touch and a great option to have around the house for bedding changes.
There are a couple of things we love about this budget-friendly find. From our testing, quilts actually move around less in duvet covers than some comforters, perhaps due to the shape of the design adding some cohesive grip so there is less sliding. If you don’t want to use a cover, that is no problem at all. This quilt is available in white, navy, pink, gray, and many more shades. It’s also double-sided, so you can simply flip it over when you’re looking for a new style.
The Nestl duvet insert is a versatile choice; offering medium weight and heat, which is ideal for most sleepers. We recommend giving this insert about two days to completely fluff up after removing it from the packaging.
Sizing: Twin — Oversized King | Material: Polyester
Pros:
- Hypoallergenic, machine washable
- Tencel eucalyptus lyocell is said to absorb moisture faster than cotton
- The free trial lets you experience Buffy for seven nights before buying
- More sustainable than other fabrics
Cons:
- Some sleepers prefer cotton over tencel (personal preference)
Sweat less, sleep more. Talk about breathability — this comforter leaves you feeling clean and refreshed when you wake up. It probably has something to do with the material. Instead of cotton, Buffy used tencel eucalyptus lyocell which is said to absorb moisture quicker than other fabrics. Buffy is still offering a seasonal sale with deep discounts. Snatch this comforter and more on sale.
Editor’s Note: “I was a skeptic at first but my illuminated skin confirmed that the breathability is there. Not to mention, Buffy is exceptionally sustainable,” shared Salemann. “The brand recycles roughly 50 plastic bottles per comforter and shreds them into marshmallowy goodness, to make your comforter extra soft but eco-friendly, too. Somehow still on the fence about this deliciously fluffy, Buffy comforter? Luckily, you can get the comforter for a free trial and pay later if you decide to keep it. If you’re unhappy for any reason you have a week to return the comforter for no cost at all.”
Sizing: Twin/TwinXL, Full/Queen, King/California King | Material: Tencel eucalyptus
Pros:
- Durable and lasts years
- Temperature-regulating wool material
- Naturally sourced hypoallergenic
Cons:
- More expensive than other feather duvets
This medium-weight British wool-filled comforter is just about as deluxe as they come. You’ll feel like British royalty wrapped up in this exceptionally high-quality product — it’s sourced straight from the iconic Chatsworth Estate, after all. Some argue wool offers superior moisture management and heat regulation than feather duvets — so we had to try it out for ourselves.
Editor’s Note: “I’ve been using my Woolroom comforter insert for almost three years now and it’s truly the best,” raved Commerce Editor and Reporter, Kendall Cornish. “It seems rather flat when you first unbox it, but it slowly and subtly puffs up within a few hours. It keeps me warm in winter and cool in summer, without fail regardless of whatever bedding I use. It’s a magic bedding essential, one I can’t recommend enough or imagine not using.”
Sizing: Twin — King | Material: Wool
Pros:
- Beautiful striped design — no duvet cover required
- A sturdy build and little stretch
- 100% Polyester Faux Fur reverses to solid Micromink
Cons:
- Micromink is on the warmer side — less ideal for hot sleepers
We all know and love UGG’s deliciously comfortable fur booties and slippers, so it’s not surprising that the Australian brand also has come out with some impressive comforters. This complete set comes with shams as well, so your entire bed will be looking snazzy in no time. Plus, for the holidays, shoppers will receive free expedited shipping on orders of $185 or more — including this comforter!
Everyone has different tastes when it comes to their bedding. For those searching for style, take a look at this 100% cotton Ava Stripe selection from UGG. The nautical, striped set comes in two stunning colorways and features faux fur and woven, textured designs on one side and soft micro mink on the other. The material is sturdy and offers little stretch (feels near tear-resistant.)
If you want a comforter that will hold up for years and look gorgeous while doing it, we would recommend this comforter again and again. Yes, it’s a bit on the pricey side, but no duvet cover is necessary. This comforter stands alone.
Sizing: Queen | Material: Polyester
Pros:
- Affordable
- Lots of color options
- Material feels durable
Cons:
- Comes out of the package a little wrinkled
For an affordable comforter that is worth every penny, we point you in the direction of the ROSGONIA set on Amazon. Customers love this fade-resistant set, and thousands of them have left rave reviews — many people have made note of its natural, earthy color and crisp feel. While it is prone to some wrinkling while folded, the marks seem to fall out once laid out on the bed.
Editor’s Note: “I’ve been hunting for a new comforter for a while. I’d really like one from Buffy or Brooklinen but until I squirrel money away for that, a pick from Amazon will have to do,” said Commerce Updates Editor, Holly J Coley. “This one was less than $50, came with two pillowcases, and is surprisingly thick — perfect for a New York winter. It’s soft, covers my queen-size bed perfectly, plus has a little extra material left over, and is fade-resistant. It did come out wrinkled from the package but it smooths fairly easily. Highly recommend for those seeking new bedding but not in the market for something expensive.”
Sizing: Twin — Super King | Material: Polyester
Pros:
- Lightweight, and breathable while still retaining a comfortable amount of heat
- 700-fill-power European white down for ultimate comfort
- Sturdy, double-stitched seams
Cons:
- Not ideal for colder sleepers
Some people have personal preferences when it comes to keeping the room warmer and veering for cooler blankets. Others live in temperate, or humid climates where a light comforter is absolutely essential. As someone who enjoys a lightweight option, I firmly stand behind Quine’s Luxe Lightweight Goose Down.
Editor’s Note: “I’ve reviewed some brands that are advertised as lightweight when they’re actually just selling comforters that appear to be thinned out,” said Salemann. “This option from Quince on the other hand, is truly thick and weightless at the same time. It’s stuffed with 700-fill-power European white down, so there is an ample amount of fluff, but the sewn-through construction reduces the weight and adds breathability. A lightweight comforter is not for everyone. If you sleep with the thermostat set to 60 degrees, you might want to consider another type of comforter. “
Sizing: Twin, Full/Queen, King/California King | Material: European Down
How we tested
To provide a comprehensive review of each comforter or duvet insert, we evaluated based on the following criteria: the overall quality, the weight of the fabric, the heat level, and the style.
Overall quality: Shoppers want to find a comforter that will last. We tested how long it took for each comforter to “fluff,” checked the lines of the seams, observed whether there was any stretch, and put the comforters inside duvet covers to see how they fit and whether they slid around or stayed in place.
Heat level: Heat level is a personal preference, some people veer on the chillier side and crave a warmer comforter, while others easily overheat and enjoy something cooler. We’ve reviewed a variety of cooling and heating comforters, to find something for every type of sleeper.
Weight of the fabric: Similar to heat level, the weight of the comforter is up to personal preference. We’ve made note of the amount of fill in the down comforters and tested out those that were designed with other fabrics (linen, bamboo, Tencel, etc.) to evaluate where they fell on the weight spectrum.
Style: Most comforters and duvet inserts are not visible underneath duvet covers, but styles still vary. Some are quilted, striped, and woven, while others are smooth and flat. We’ve also considered a few brands that do offer inserts and comforters in a variety of shades so they do not require a cover.
How should you put a duvet cover on your comforter?
Per Martha Stewart’s suggestions, the first step is to lay the duvet cover inside-out and place your insert or comforter on top of the inside-out duvet cover.
Working from the top of the bed, roll both the duvet cover and insert or comforter downward towards the end of the bed.
Once you arrive at the end of the bed, twist and invert the bottom sleeve of the duvet cover around each end of the duvet insert or comforter. The top side of the duvet cover should be facing out, which will allow you to close it with zippers, buttons, or ties.
What materials should you consider in a comforter?
Nowadays, duvet inserts and comforters can be found in a range of materials, from natural duck or goose down feathers to other synthetic fillings — such as cotton, bamboo, mulberry silk, linen, and Tencel.
Each material has a unique texture, heat, and weight, which is important to consider your sleep habits and environment when picking out the right duvet cover or comforter.
Check out New York Post Shopping for more content.
For over 200 years, the New York Post has been America’s go-to source for bold news, engaging stories, in-depth reporting, and now, insightful shopping guidance. We’re not just thorough reporters – we sift through mountains of information, test and compare products, and consult experts on any topics we aren’t already schooled specialists in to deliver useful, realistic product recommendations based on our extensive and hands-on analysis. Here at The Post, we’re known for being brutally honest – we clearly label partnership content, and whether we receive anything from affiliate links, so you always know where we stand. We routinely update content to reflect current research and expert advice, provide context (and wit) and ensure our links work. Please note that deals can expire, and all prices are subject to change.